Local reporting goes international
By Andrew Grant-Adamson • May 12th, 2007 • Category: Journalism, OnlineIt probably takes a non-journalist to even think of the possibility of covering city hall from 8,000 miles away. Yet that is what James McPherson, founder, editor and publisher of Pasadena Now has done.
The very idea of outsourcing local reporting to India sent a shudder through me. But what is the real objection? Council meetings are on the internet and the telephone works pretty well these days. A good reporter in India (and there are plenty of them) will probably do a better job than a second-rate local.
McPherson, who apparently has no experience as a journalist, told Forbes: “I think it could be a significant way to increase the quality of journalism on the local level without the expense that is a major problem for local publications. Whether you’re at a desk in Pasadena or a desk in Mumbai, you’re still just a phone call or e-mail away from the interview.”
With two Indian journalists costing a bit over £5,000 a year each in wages the attraction to an employer is evident.
Mark Potts, who is on the board of Backfence.com, sees it differently:
This is ridiculous, and not just because every locally televised city council meeting I’ve ever seen is a hard-to-follow broadcasting travesty. As any journalist knows, there’s just no substitute for firsthand experience, actually being in the room, sensing the tenor of the audience and, most importantly, being able to buttonhole players in the story for interviews. It makes no sense. Would anybody even think of covering India from Pasadena? I think not. It won’t work in the other direction, either.
And you know what? Citizen journalism would be even cheaper. Maybe McPherson should find somebody in the community who’s passionate about what goes on in the city council, and let them file reports. You don’t have to go halfway around the world to find somebody to cover a local story.
I agree with Potts. The people who report on a community should be part of that community, sharing its culture and values.But another side of me says I have come across many good Indian journalists who could just pull this off. Shudder!
Andrew Grant-Adamson is Andrew Grant-Adamson is a journalist who now teaches a new generation of writers, subs and editors at the University of Westminster.
Email this author | All posts by Andrew Grant-Adamson
. To be included (entirely at our discretion), the blog must be predominantly about journalism and/or add some genuine insight into the state of the profession and technological developments affecting it. Local reporting goes international It probably takes a non-journalist to even think of the possibility of covering city hall from 8,000 miles away. Yet that is what James McPherson, founder, editor and publisher of Pasadena Now has …
[...] Associated Press article by Justin Pritchard: Calif. Web Site Outsources Reporting Topix: It’s official: Local reporting is doomed Peoria Pundits: It’s official: Local reporting is doomed Foothill Cities*: PasadenaNow Outsources Local News Coverage (includes the text of the Bangalore Craigslist ad) Editors’ Corner*: Local coverage from afar LA Observed: Pasadena News Site Outsources to India Journalism and the World: I’m not the only one looking to hire from India Journalism.co.uk: Local news reporting outsourced to India Ed Driscoll.com: You can’t make this stuff up latimes.com: Local news reporting outsourced to India pasadenastarnews.com*: The news coming from afar Cincom Smalltalk: Dumb and Dumber Neil Sanderson: Outsourcing journalism to cut costs West Coast Grrly Blather*: Pasadena Weekly Dan Gillmor, Center for Citizen Media Blog: Outsourced Journalism The Doc Searls Weblog: Virtual is free. Being there costs ya. The Curious Capitalist: The Indian labor arbitrage opportunity is shrinking fast Reason Magazine - Hit & Run: Outsourcing to India: Now It’s a Tragedy mathewingram.com/work: Covering Pasadena from 9,000 miles away Not as Much Fun in Real Life: Life Imitates Art Queenkv’s Brainpickings: Outsourcing the News: Hiring reporters in India to cover Pasadena, CA Editor’s Corner*: Larry Wilson, Pasadena Star News editor, gets a couple of chuckles out of me… The Huffington Post Eat the Press: India to U.S. Media: “We in Ur Webz, Replacin Ur Punditz!” The Atlantic Online, Matthew Yglesias: Uh-Oh Under the Dome*: Namaskar FP Passport: Local Pasadena news written by … journalists in India Lost Remote TV Blog: Hyperlocal site outsourcing news coverage to India LAist: Pasadena Now Outsources Newswriting From India spill: monument quiet Mobile Blog - InformationWeek: My Cousin In Mumbai Could Have Written That Miss Havisham’s Tea Party*: Journalistic Objectivity May Be An Indian Thing BPO Tiger: US newspaper Pasadena.com outsources local journalism jobs to India iowas newz liter: I am thinking Progressive Gold: Watch Out, Joe Klein… Guardian Unlimited: On the news beat in Mumbai, California darleeneisms: Reporting live on Pasadena, from India Common Sense Journalism: Mumbai calling … Reuters: It’s a long way to Pasadena deepikaglobal.com: India-based journalists wanted for US city reporting USC Annenberg Online Journalism Review, Robert Niles*: Should publishers outsource journalism? Recovering Journalist: Far-Outsourcing Reflections of a Newsosaur: All-out outsourcingWordblog: Local reporting goes international [...]
[...] blogger who can’t totally condemn this is Andrew Grant-Adamson, who writes: I agree with Potts. The people who report on a community should be part of that [...]
Andrew,
I read this story in yesterday’s Guardian and was I could not believe that this was actually happening.
Mark is completely correct,to be able to report on the local community you have to be a part of it,understand its problems,concerns etc.This is simply a way for the paper concerned to save on money and resources.This is not journalism
[...] Wordblog: Local reporting goes international [...]